MyWheelName.com Guides
Random MLS Team Draws
By My Wheel Name TeamPublished July 25, 20262 min read
MLS is the football league where a random team draw behaves least like the European ones, because the American franchise model changes what a season actually is.
No relegation changes the stakes
There's no relegation, so a badly performing club isn't playing for survival. It's playing for draft position and a rebuild, which is a completely different kind of season to follow.
That removes the drama European fans expect from the bottom of a table, and replaces it with something else: every club is permanent, so the club the wheel gives you will still be there in five years.
Two trophies, two seasons
The Supporters' Shield goes to the best regular season record. The MLS Cup is decided by playoffs. They're separate honours and they frequently go to different clubs.
For a random draw that's genuinely good news. A drawn team can have an ordinary regular season and still win everything in November, which is structurally impossible in a European league where the table is the whole competition.
The roster rules are the interesting part
- A salary cap applies, unlike in European football, so clubs can't simply outspend each other.
- The Designated Player rule, universally called the Beckham rule after the 2007 signing that prompted it, lets each club pay a small number of stars outside the cap.
- That means a drawn club's ceiling often depends on two or three signings rather than overall wealth.
- Expansion continues, so the league is still adding franchises and the wheel grows with it.
Where the draw gets used
Playoff sweepstakes are the most common use, since a single elimination format makes any drawn club a plausible winner. Fantasy tiebreakers are next.
It also works well as a way into the league for someone who follows European football and finds the American structure confusing. Following one franchise for a season teaches the rules faster than reading about them.
Spin, note the conference, and take the playoffs seriously regardless of the regular season. In this league those are close to separate competitions.
Questions, answered
Is there relegation in MLS?
No. Clubs are franchises and stay in the league permanently, so a poorly performing team is playing for draft position and a rebuild rather than survival. That's the main structural difference from European leagues.
What's the difference between the Supporters' Shield and the MLS Cup?
The Shield goes to the best regular season record and the Cup is decided by playoffs. They're separate honours that often go to different clubs, so a drawn team can have a mediocre season and still win the Cup.
What is the Designated Player rule?
It lets each club pay a small number of players outside the salary cap. It's universally called the Beckham rule after the 2007 signing that created it, and it's how the league keeps attracting marquee names despite the cap.
Does the wheel include new expansion teams?
Yes. The league is still expanding and the wheel reflects the current set of clubs rather than a fixed list, so newly added franchises appear as they join.
How do I keep the games watchable in my time zone?
Trim the wheel to one conference before spinning. The league spans a continent, so an unfiltered draw can hand a European or east coast viewer a club whose home games kick off very late.